Anthony Collins Solicitors is pleased to have been ranked as a Band 1 firm once again.
We have been working with care homes to update their contracts and advise on the risks of charging the resident a regular “top-up” or additional fee where a resident is funded through NHS Continuing Healthcare ("CHC").
The risk of getting these arrangements wrong is shown by recent enforcement action by the Competition and Markets Authority (“CMA”) which has resulted in a £1 million refund to NHS-funded residents at Care UK’s premium care homes.
The CMA’s 2018 guidance ‘Care homes: consumer law advice for providers’ confirmed providers are more likely to infringe consumer law where they:
- demand a regular top-up to the weekly fee to cover a claimed ‘shortfall’ in the CHC funding (either as a condition of moving into the home or as a condition of staying in the home);
- ask a resident to sign an agreement (or to be invoiced) for the provision of additional private services, when these are not in fact provided and the true purpose of the payment is to cover a claimed ‘shortfall’ in the CHC funding; and
- require or otherwise pressurise a CHC resident to purchase additional services as a condition of moving into the home or continuing to allow them to remain in the home as an NHS-funded resident.
Many providers experience difficulties where NHS funding does not cover the price of a room at the home and some have sought to remedy this by charging residents for additional services or facilities on offer at the home.
It is permissible to charge residents for additional private services or ‘lifestyle choices’, such as aromatherapy, beauty treatments or extra sessions of physiotherapy, which are distinguishable from the care and accommodation necessary to meet their essential care. However, the CMA considers that Care UK broke consumer protection law by charging additional fees that did not relate to purely voluntary purchases and instead contributed towards essential care. The CMA has also clarified that ‘essential care’ refers to the care package that meets an individual’s health and social care needs.
Following enforcement action by the CMA, Care UK has agreed to repay NHS funded residents by the end of November 2020, with the majority of residents receiving more than £1,000 and some substantially more. It has also committed to stop charging this additional fee altogether for residents at its homes.
Providers will need to take care of how they distinguish between services that meet residents’ essential care and services that are genuinely ‘added extras’. It is very unlikely that enhanced quality of service or superior amenities will justify an additional fee if they cannot be separated from the general package of care and accommodation.
For more information
We have been supporting providers to navigate this complex area of consumer law and the impact of NHS rules upon their charging structures. For more information about the impact this may have upon your CHC funded residents, please contact Emma Watt or John Wearing.
Details of Care UK’s undertaking, which includes example wording which it is now prohibited from using, is available here.
Since March 2020, commercial property owners and occupiers across many sectors, whether housing associations, charities, care providers or local authorities, have been impacted by the rules regulating how they deal with their tenants and their landlords. It seems each week there is a change in policy, regulation or legislation, governing how they must respond.
A key element of the Bill is the establishment of a duty holder regime and requirement to maintain the ‘golden thread of information’ throughout the life cycle of high-risk residential buildings
We have been working with care homes to update their contracts and advise on the risks of charging the resident a regular “top-up” or additional fee where a resident is funded through NHS CHC
The parliamentary processes are complete and the Restriction of Public Exit Payments Regulations 2020 (“the Regulations”) which cap exit payments in the public sector at £95,000 will be in force from 4 November.
As the UK’s social housing sector recovers from the initial Covid-19 outbreak and lockdown, now is the time to focus on the challenges that may emerge next.
There is no universal approach to regenerating town centres. However, housing must be considered a key part of any regeneration project – providing well-needed new homes and economic growth.
Friday 16 October marks the 6th annual Wear Red Day in England, Wales and Scotland. Wear Red Day is the brainchild of the charity; Show Racism the Red Card (SRTRC). SRTRC aims to educate young people so they are equipped to recognise and challenge stereotypes, misconceptions and negative attitudes towards race.
Alongside the Building Safety Bill published in July 2020, the Fire Safety Bill is a key step in the Government’s strategy to improve building and fire safety in the wake of the Grenfell Tower tragedy
Government regulations came into force on 23 September 2020 providing LGPS (local government pension scheme) employers with flexibility on meeting exit payments and LGPS funds with flexibility too
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.