A recent study revealed that only 65% of appeals were allowed in cases where councillors refused planning permission despite planning officers’ recommendation for approval.
As creatures of statute, local authorities can only do those things that they are empowered to do, or those that are reasonably ancillary or incidental to those powers.
This has caused many problems over the years, and Parliament has, from time to time, tried to increase the ability of Local Authorities by introducing more “generic” powers. These, for example, included the “well-being” power under the Local Government Act 2000 (now repealed) and, more recently, the “general power of competence” within the Localism Act 2011. It should be noted that the well-being power remains in Wales, whilst the general power of competence only applies in England.
When these matters have gone before the courts, they have however got a history of interpreting legislation intended to provide for a breadth of powers in a more restrictive manner than one supposes Parliament originally intended. To date, the test of the “general power of competence” in the courts has not emerged. It’s always worth noting however that the general power of competence gives an authority the powers of individual, and many things that a local authority may wish to do are outside the powers of an individual!
Whether or not a local authority has indeed the powers to carry out the activity it wishes to do, is something that is always at the front of the mind of a local authority lawyer. This goes further and looks at whether or not such a matter is either an executive or a council matter, something that is, despite the introduction of the executive/council split with the Local Government Act 2000, still causes problems, as it is not always clear as to where the dividing line is.
Whatever the issue with local authority powers and duties, we have vast experience of navigating the whole range of the issues that need to be considered in relation to whether or not local authorities have the powers and how they should go about exercising these. This includes for example:
- Local authority powers and duties;
- Powers and duties of other public bodies;
- Internal governance considerations for councils;
- Clear and effective decision making;
- Consultation processes;
- Executive/council split;
- Proportionality and the impact of the proportionality;
- Council chairman and committee chairman;
- Constitutional issues;
- Standing orders;
- Financial regulations;
- Member/officer protocol;
- Code of Conduct and member complaints;
- Senior officer employment matters;
- Officer/member decision making; and
Our team of expert solicitors regularly advise councils on issues of vires, decision-making and the duties that councils have. This includes matters such as charging for service delivery, setting up companies, directors' responsibilities, charities and member conduct and investigations. We are leading specialists in this area and are extremely active in relation to investigations, and the powers needed and utilised by local authorities in setting up new delivery mechanisms.
A specialist in legal and strategic advice to local authorities.
We have been recognised for the work we do
The Government has now published its “no deal notice” for public procurement.
Join Olwen Dutton, Matthew Gregson and Alex Lawrence in our latest webinar to discuss the decision in R (Harvey) v Ledbury Town Council.
The European Court of Justice has confirmed the recent opinion that a state-funded school, providing free education, is subject to the European Union’s rules on unfair contract terms.
The High Court Ruling in R(Harvey) v Ledbury Town Council has clarified how a council should deal with complaints against a councillor & has implications for Town & Parish Councils throughout England.
The Department for Education has approved the setting up of 5 new adoption agencies involving a total of 17 councils.
Another case that might challenge holiday-pay practice for variable hours staff has been decided by the EAT.
Anthony Collins Solicitors (ACS) won four awards at the Birmingham Law Society Awards last night (8 March 2018), including Law Firm of the Year (16 partners or more).
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.