The CQC will conduct reviews on a monthly basis of all of the information they hold about services and will use these reviews to prioritise its activity.
In a previous ebriefing we profiled the case of Commission v Austria*, in which Wiener Wohnen (a contracting authority linked to the City of Vienna) contracted for a landowning developer to grant to them a 25-year lease of a new head office building they were constructing on that land.
The Advocate General had said that the arrangements were an unlawfully let public works contract because Wiener Wohnen had exercised a ‘decisive influence' over the design and construction of the building.
The European Court of Justice, who has the last word on this, came to the opposite conclusion. They said that the level of influence over the work did not amount to a decisive influence since it, “did not exceed the usual requirements of a tenant in relation to a building such as the complex concerned”.
The court said that a contracting authority will exercise a decisive influence over the design of a building if they “exercise that influence over the architectural structure of the building, such as its size, external walls and load-bearing walls".
However, they said that “stipulations concerning interior fittings may be regarded as demonstrating a decisive influence only if they are distinguished because of their specificity or scale”.
The choice of options offered by the developer was also insufficient to amount to a decisive influence.
This improves the prospects of a contracting authority being able to argue that, where properties are being constructed for them, the arrangements will not be a public works contract. This should now be arguable if the contracting authority has no more control over the design or construction of the development than would be usual for an 'off-plan' purchaser.
In many cases, a contracting authority will want greater control than this. For a limited number of cases, though, where the authority is paying a deposit and the balance on completion (rather than stage payments or payments against valuations under a JCT contract) and is content with the developer’s standard house types, it may be able to argue that the arrangements are a land transaction rather than a public works contract. This is a developing area of procurement law, though, and great care is needed over these kinds of arrangements.
For more information
For advice on whether a potential development structure is likely to be classified as a public works contract and how to deal with this, please contact Andrew Millross or your usual contact within our construction and procurement department.
*Commission v Republic of Austria, Case C-537/19
In June 2021 the Education and Skills Funding Agency ESFA issued its annual update to their Academies Financial Handbook. The purpose of this briefing is to summarise the changes and any particular ac
From 30 September 2021, the costs of issuing certain applications in the Family Court will increase, following the implementation of the Court Fees Order.
Are your board members or trustees doing any of these three things with their emails, which are a risk to both your resources and relationships?
Must a defended possession claim at first hearing be adjourned with directions?
Thomas Starkey has been recruited to help lead Anthony Collins Solicitors housing practice, with the remit of growing ACS’ Manchester office and property team.
The monthly round-up from the Anthony Collins Solicitors charities team.
Since GDPR has come into effect, many companies have struggled to comply with GDPR. In this ebriefing, we look at the shocking data breach at Hackney Council.
The High Court has ruled that retrospective changes to the LGPS exit credits regime were lawful – and gave some helpful guidance around the new discretion to pay an exit credit.
The Government has brought forward draft laws to allow independent schools to close the Teacher’s Pension Scheme to new joiners but to allow existing members to continue.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.