In the Transforming Public Procurement Green Paper, the Government signalled its desire to increase its control over procurements by all contracting authorities.
Unfortunately, what the programme did not do is highlight the good care and practice that is delivered by social care providers and their care workers everyday across the country. For the majority of care providers, who are providing excellent care, programmes such as this can be very demoralising at a time of reduced funding and often over prescriptive regulation. Nevertheless, the programme does raise important issues that highlight the challenging times in which the underfunded and the understaffed home care sector operates.
The programme came close on the heels of the widely reported case and recent sentencing of a care worker at Birmingham Magistrates’ Court, who was caught slamming the head of a 77-year old woman with dementia into a chair on secret CCTV – again installed by her family. In both cases, the wrongdoers were successfully brought to justice under The Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 (s20 Ill-treatment or wilful neglect: care worker offence) that came into force on 13 April 2015 and states, "It is an offence for an individual who has the care of another individual by virtue of being a care worker to ill-treat or wilfully to neglect that individual". This legislation can be used in addition to the Mental Capacity Act 2005, which states that it is a criminal offence for care workers who ill-treat or wilfully neglect service users, but only in relation to service users who lack capacity and only care workers (rather than care providers – as with CJCA 2015) can be liable*.
'File on Four' went on to report that an extraordinary number of safeguarding referrals, in relation to allegations of abuse (23,000) by home care workers, were made in the last three years. The programme did not give details about the outcomes of the referrals but it is hoped that, whilst this an alarming trend, it should also be welcomed that bad practice is under the spotlight and referrals are being made. It would be very interesting to know how many safeguarding referrals were made directly by care providers or how many allegations proved to be upheld. It is our experience that referrals are being made as a matter of routine by many of our clients. Many are keen for any concerns to be investigated, even where they appear trivial or supported by little evidence. We find that providers do not condone any deliberate act or omission by care staff designed to harm or distress a client. Basic ethical principles make it clear how healthcare professionals should make the care of their clients their primary concern. These should not need to be spelled out. Unfortunately mistakes do sometimes happen, even by carers working for outstanding providers. These are often as a result of rushed home care visits, which are limited by the amount of time that is commissioned by local authorities.
The programme highlighted the difficulty with the definitions of abuse and neglect, which can often be fluid. Whilst in the context of criminal proceedings, wilful neglect will have an element of conscious decision making, rather than recklessness or negligence. The Crown Prosecution Service confirms that there is no simple offence for the "neglect" of an older person, other than in those circumstances set out in the Mental Capacity Act 2005 or the Mental Health Act 1983. In the context of the Coroner’s Court “neglect” is defined as “a gross failure to provide adequate sustenance, medical attention or shelter for a person in a position of dependency, whether by reason of a physical or mental condition”. The term "abuse" is used to describe a wide range of behaviours, many of which are, in fact, are covered by other offences.
Highlighting the quality of your care to local authorities, at times like this, is important and can help when negotiating fee increases. It is also likely that there will now be more appetite for the police to bring prosecutions against care providers who find themselves in the unfortunate situation where they have to defend proceedings.
For further information
For further information on our regulatory offering, see our website or contact Sarah Knight. We can assist with advice in relation to safeguarding referrals, police processions, coroner proceedings, or support with funding negotiations.
*A care provider will be guilty of an offence if:
- One of its care workers ill treats or wilfully neglects a service user under its care;
- The way in which the provider manages or organises its activities amounts to a gross breach of a relevant duty of care owed to the service user;
- Without that breach, the ill-treatment or wilful neglect would not have occurred or would have been less likely to occur; and
- The wording of the offence mirrors that used for corporate manslaughter. In particular, there must be a gross breach of duty by the provider rather than simply a failure to take reasonable care.
The monthly round-up from the Anthony Collins Solicitors charities team.
Legal updates as the UK enters into stage 4 of the roadmap and legal restrictions on face coverings and social distancing are lifted.
The first disability we are going to discuss is diabetes. We begin by discussing the different types of diabetes; their similarities and differences and how we live with the disability within our day.
Tim Coolican and Freya Cassia explore the legal and practical options available to providers if a disappointing result is received following an inspection.
Following the launch of the CQC’s new strategy for how it regulates health and social care, many providers will be keen to know more about how the changes might affect them in the future.
EPC’s are not required to be served with a Section 21 notice for assured shorthold tenancies if the tenancy predates October 2015.
A new era of paperless property deals is upon us following the Land Registry’s landmark decision in July 2020 to accept e-signed documents for registration.
Under NHSX, the Department of Health and Social Care, NHS England and NHS Improvement have published the Secretary of State's vision for how data will be used to improve health and care.
Ofsted recently published the findings from its rapid review of sexual abuse in schools and colleges. The review highlighted keys areas of concern and presents clear actions, which are discussed here.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.