
We summarise the outcome of the High Court case ruling against Kingston-upon-Thames RBC and which landlords may need to take action and when, regarding compensation for overcharging water bills.
This case concerned a charitable foundation in Norway, Stiftelsen Fossumkollektivet (SF). SF offers residential care for young people with drug and/or alcohol problems and has therapists living on site with the patients.
SF introduced a change to their working arrangements so that the resident therapists would work for 7 days and then have a 7 day rest period. During their working days, the therapists would work from 7am until 11pm (with a 2 hour break) and be required to be available during the night.
Some of the therapists refused to accept the new working patterns and were issued with notices of dismissal and offered re-engagement on the new terms. The therapists challenged the new arrangements as they felt they breached the EU Working Time Directive.
The Norwegian court sent three questions for consideration by the EFTA (European Free Trade Association Court), one of which concerned this issue.
The therapists argued that because they were entitled to a daily rest period of 11 hours and a weekly rest period of 24 hours (totalling 90 hours) this only left 78 hours each week that they could work.
The EFTA Court disagreed with this and held that an 84 hour working week was capable of being compatible with the EU Working Time Directive. The 48 hour limit could be varied subject to:
The requirement to provide daily and weekly rest periods is subject to the exemptions set out in the legislation. One of these relates to activities requiring continuity of service, including in regards to services connected with the treatment and/or care provided by hospitals or similar establishments. If this applies and rest periods are missed, compensatory rest should be provided immediately following the working time the compensatory rest is supposed to counteract. However, there is also scope for exceptional circumstances where compensatory rest cannot be provided for objective reasons, in these circumstances, workers should be given appropriate protection.
It was also relevant that the reason the therapists were resident was because it was beneficial for the young people to have the same therapists present for long periods of time. This meant it was possible that the activities being performed by the therapists could make it impossible, for objective reasons, to grant periods of rest. On this basis, provided that the requirements of the exemptions were met, an 84 hour working week in a residential care arrangement could be compatible with the EU Working Time Directive.
Points to note
If you require advice in relation to the obligation to provide rest periods and the available derogations, please contact Faye Rush.
We summarise the outcome of the High Court case ruling against Kingston-upon-Thames RBC and which landlords may need to take action and when, regarding compensation for overcharging water bills.
It is important to remember that when it comes to selling services, you must deliver on your promises.
Under section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act (HSWA) 1974, organisations are obligated to avoid public health and safety risks through the conduct of their business.
How does a media-savvy employer ensure a season of festive cheer but without mishap, damage to their reputation or harassment and bullying claims?
Providers need to be alive to the risk of contractors becoming insolvent and how to limit the resulting inevitable disruption.
Housing associations must continue to deliver core functions effectively and compliantly notwithstanding the uncertainty over the standards to which you will be held in the future.
Over the last few years the meaning of “asset management” has changed from being all about repairs to understanding that assets might not stay in an organisation forever.
The Grenfell Tower tragedy has understandably prompted a fundamental reconsideration of how building safety is approached for High-Rise Residential Buildings.
Results from the latest three-yearly valuation of the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) are starting to trickle through.
The potential for Brexit with or without a deal causes uncertainty, and credit rating agencies do not like uncertainty.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.