Home › Insights › Blog › Serious incidents: managing processes but...

Serious incidents: managing processes but not forgetting the people involved

16 November 2026 6 min read
Serious incidents: managing processes but not forgetting the people involved

A recent tragic case was reported about a 26-year-old Treasury employee who took her own life a day after being informed by her employer of allegations made against her regarding potential breaches of confidentiality.  The coroner reported that this informal meeting materially contributed to her death.  The meeting - labelled an informal fact-finding meeting - was Treasury practice, but the coroner found that it was not actually part of their disciplinary policy.  The manager at the meeting should have confirmed, in accordance with their policy, that if the allegations were proven then the sanction would have been a written warning. Instead, the manager, when asked by Ms Moffat whether she was going to be sacked, told her that they could not predict the outcome. This led her to believe she was to be sacked.   

This was an extremely sad case and thankfully not a common one; however, it is worth addressing the lessons that can be learnt. 

  • How do employers balance the need to investigate allegations of a serious nature, whilst also being mindful of the duty of care owed to the employee concerned and their welfare?
  • What is the impact of the involvement of the coroner and how should employers respond?

Is an informal stage in a disciplinary process advantageous or detrimental as it was in this case? 

Informal resolution of issues is often a good place to start, and it is encouraged by the ACAS code on disciplinary and grievances. It provides an opportunity for allegations to be raised with the employee to see if there are misunderstandings or issues that can be addressed without recourse to a formal process. The key is that managers or staff involved are clear about the purpose and boundaries of this step in the process; it is not an investigation nor a disciplinary meeting and it should not result in the employee feeling ambushed and worried for their future within the organisation.   

Open questions such as “can you help me understand what happened in this situation” rather than closed statements such as “you could be facing a disciplinary sanction” should be used. It may not be wise in every situation to call an informal meeting – the ACAS code does not require it – and so it should be clear in your policy when the step is not helpful or relevant. Where serious allegations have been made, or a serious incident has occurred, an informal stage in the process may not be appropriate.

How do we ensure we investigate issues thoroughly whilst also being mindful of our duty of care to the employee concerned?

ACAS notes that “going through a disciplinary procedure can be very stressful. It's important that employers consider the wellbeing and mental health of their employees”.  Following a fair disciplinary procedure which mirrors the ACAS code should ensure the employee is given fair warning of any allegations, given sufficient notice of any meetings and their right to be accompanied and given clear written confirmation of any steps to be taken and why.  These steps, if carefully followed, are the bedrock to addressing the stressful situation of a disciplinary process. 

You should also consider how you support employees during the process; whether you provide them with a key person they can contact in your HR team and/or whether you give them details of an employee support organisation or another alternative. Employees may outwardly appear calm and undeterred by the process. That might, however, mask worry and stress and providing confidential and independent support provides necessary support. Employers should aim to provide several places where employees can access support; different people will seek different types of support. 

All these steps, including the support available to the employee, must be documented clearly to demonstrate what steps have been taken. 

Training managers is key 

It is neither fair on the manager nor the employee to expect an efficient, empathetic and reasonable disciplinary process without a clear understanding of the process. Providing a manager with a copy of the disciplinary policy and possibly some guidance notes is not sufficient to equip them, especially if the matter is complex. A badly run disciplinary process can prove costly both financially and in management time and the risk of a tribunal claim is a clear one. If allegations relate to a serious matter or a serious incident has occurred, the impact of a poorly run process can be damaging to those involved. In the worst case scenario, as we saw with Lucy Moffat, it can be devastating. 

To mitigate this risk, we advise organisations to consider carefully what training is provided to their staff, how frequently it is provided and how they ensure that these processes are being run effectively.  Please do contact a member of our team for more information on the course we provide. 

What might a coroner be interested in when considering circumstances such as these?

Coroners are not responsible for determining civil or employment liability; they are concerned with understanding how a death occurred and identifying opportunities to prevent future deaths. In recent years, coroners have increasingly examined the interaction between organisational processes and individual vulnerability. The question is often not simply whether an employer followed its policies, but whether the way a process was conducted may have contributed to the outcome and whether any lessons can be learned for the future.

How is a coroner's focus different from an employer's focus?

As noted above, employers will be concerned with complying with their policies and procedures and the ACAS code. A coroner's question may be slightly different: was there anything about the way the process was conducted that created or exacerbated a foreseeable risk of serious harm? That does not mean organisations should avoid difficult conversations or delay investigations into misconduct. However, it does highlight the importance of considering not only what is communicated, but how it is communicated, whether the purpose of meetings and likely next steps are clearly explained, and whether appropriate support is available throughout the process. This mirrors to some extent what an employer should already be doing.  

What steps can organisations take following a serious incident?

The period immediately following a serious incident is often challenging for everyone involved. Organisations will need to balance supporting employees and others affected by the incident with understanding what has happened and responding to external scrutiny. Depending on the circumstances, that may include engaging with the police, regulators and the coroner, whilst also preserving evidence and ensuring appropriate records are retained.  External legal advice at such a critical time can be invaluable.  At the same time, organisations should begin considering what lessons can be learned from the incident. Internal reviews, policy amendments, management training and clear evidence that improvements have been implemented can be just as important as explaining the events which led to the death.

How can organisations reduce the likelihood of a Prevention of Future Deaths report?

Coroners have powers to issue Prevention of Future Deaths reports where they identify concerns that give rise to a risk of future deaths. However, a Prevention of Future Deaths report is not intended to punish organisations for what has happened, but to address concerns about what might happen next. An organisation that can demonstrate it has already identified the issue, reflected upon it and implemented effective remedial action is often in a much stronger position when those concerns are being considered. Evidence of policy changes, additional training, revised guidance or other practical improvements can significantly reduce the perceived need for a report.

Going forward…..

Ultimately, employers should remember that difficult conversations are often unavoidable, but avoidable misunderstandings should not be. Clear communication, regular training on up to date and compliant policies coupled with appropriate support and a willingness to reflect on and learn from adverse events will not only help organisations navigate scrutiny when things go wrong but may also reduce the risk of similar tragedies occurring in the future.

For further information or advice, please get in touch. 

Search