Home › Insights › Blog › Forced entry: A continuing judicial...

Forced entry: A continuing judicial divide

18 November 2026 3 min read
Forced entry: A continuing judicial divide

A recent County Court decision has added to the growing judicial debate over whether landlords can obtain court orders permitting forced entry where tenants repeatedly refuse access for inspections and repairs. In Phoenix Community Housing v Winch, District Judge Cridge reaffirmed his position (from Southern Housing v Emmanuel) that the Court has no power to authorise a landlord to force entry into a tenant's home. See our previous blog on Southern Housing here.

The facts

The claimant, Phoenix Community Housing Association Limited, sought access to a tenant's flat after reports of widespread damp and mould. Despite numerous appointments being arranged, the tenant repeatedly failed to provide access. The landlord therefore sought:

  1. An injunction requiring the tenant to permit access; and
  2. An order allowing it to instruct a locksmith and force entry if access continued to be refused.  

The court granted the access injunction but reserved judgment on the landlord's request for forced entry. 

The decision

District Judge Cridge held that the court does not have jurisdiction to authorise forced entry into a tenant's home in order to enforce either an express or implied contractual right of access. The judge considered that neither CPR 70.2A nor any other procedural rule can create a substantive power that Parliament has not conferred to allow forced access. 

The court also rejected the argument that tenancy provisions allowing forced entry in emergencies could justify the order sought. Even if such a contractual right existed, the judge held that a tenancy agreement cannot confer powers on the court that do not otherwise exist. 

Instead, landlords must rely on traditional remedies, including:

  • injunctions requiring access;
  • contempt proceedings where injunctions are breached; and
  • possession proceedings in appropriate cases. 

How does this compare with earlier cases?

The decision directly conflicts with recent County Court authorities.

In Stonewater Limited v Harris [2026] EWCC 42, HHJ Glen concluded that CPR 70.2A allows a landlord to obtain a forced-entry order after a tenant fails to comply with an access injunction. The judge considered the "act required" by the injunction to be enabling the landlord to obtain access, which could, where necessary, be achieved by a locksmith. 

Similarly, in Bromford Housing Association Limited v Robinson, Recorder Jack held that CPR 70.2A could operate as a form of court-authorised self-help, permitting forced entry where a tenant had failed to comply with an injunction requiring access.  

By contrast, District Judge Cridge followed his earlier decision in Southern Housing v Emmanuel, maintaining that forced entry requires express statutory authority and that procedural rules cannot override tenants' substantive rights of exclusive possession. 

Why does it matter?

The significance of Winch lies not only in the outcome but in the continuing inconsistency between County Court decisions. Social landlords are under increasing pressure to investigate damp, mould, gas safety and electrical safety issues promptly, yet access refusals remain common.

The judgment recognises that the issue is of wider importance to the social housing sector and expressly notes that higher court guidance is needed. Until appellate authority is obtained, landlords are likely to face uncertainty as to whether forced-entry orders are available and, if so, in what circumstances.  

For now, Winch represents the clearest recent statement of the restrictive approach: while courts can compel tenants to provide access, they cannot themselves authorise landlords to cross the threshold by force. 

For an overview of the case law to date, please see our blogs here and here.

ForAgainst
Sovereign Housing v Hall (July 2024)  
 Southern Housing v Emmanuel (Nov 2025) 
Taylor Clark v Mohammed (March 2026)  
Plymouth v Hammond (May 2026) 
Stonewater Limited v Harris (2026) 
Bromford v Robinson (October 2026)  
 Phoenix v Winch (Nov 2026)

Search