Home › Insights › Blog › Court of Appeal provides welcome...

Court of Appeal provides welcome clarity on mortgagee exclusion clauses

18 November 2026 3 min read
Court of Appeal provides welcome clarity on mortgagee exclusion clauses

Mortgagee exclusion clauses are a familiar feature of affordable housing planning obligations. They play a critical role in enabling registered providers to access funding by ensuring that, in certain circumstances, lenders can realise the value of their security free from affordable housing restrictions.

Without this protection, lenders would generally value affordable housing stock at significantly lower levels, restricting the ability of housing associations and registered providers to raise finance for new development and investment.

A recent Court of Appeal decision has now provided important clarification on how these provisions should be interpreted.

The case concerned a Westminster development where a section 106 agreement required 16 flats to be provided as affordable housing. The homes were leased to a registered provider, Kinsman Housing.

Following Kinsman's removal from the register of social housing providers, an event of default occurred under its financing arrangements. The lender exercised its power of sale and disposed of the affordable housing units to a purchaser that intended to let them on the open market.

Westminster City Council argued that the purchaser should remain bound by the affordable housing obligations because Kinsman was no longer a registered provider at the time of the sale.

The purchaser contended that the relevant question was whether Kinsman was a registered provider when the mortgage was originally granted, not at the date of enforcement.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the purchaser and dismissed Westminster's appeal.

In doing so, the Court reaffirmed established principles for interpreting section 106 agreements. As with other legal documents, the wording must be considered objectively, taking into account the natural meaning of the language used, the wider context of the agreement and its overall commercial purpose.

Importantly, the Court recognised the practical consequences of Westminster's interpretation. If mortgagee protection could fall away simply because a registered provider lost its registration status, lenders would face a significant and unpredictable reduction in the value of their security.

That uncertainty would have obvious consequences for funding decisions, lending terms and the availability of finance across the affordable housing sector.

What does this mean?

The decision provides reassurance to all parties involved in affordable housing delivery.

For lenders, it confirms that mortgagee exclusion clauses will generally operate in accordance with their intended commercial purpose, protecting security values where lenders are required to enforce.

For registered providers, the judgment supports continued access to funding on more favourable terms, helping unlock investment in both new affordable housing and existing stock.

For developers, the decision helps maintain confidence in a long-established mechanism that underpins the viability and deliverability of many affordable housing schemes.

The judgment serves as a reminder of the importance of carefully drafted section 106 agreements and the significant commercial consequences that can flow from seemingly technical wording.

While each agreement will turn on its own terms, the Court of Appeal has sent a clear message that mortgagee exclusion clauses should be interpreted in a way that gives effect to their commercial purpose rather than undermining the financing arrangements on which affordable housing delivery depends.

Westminster City Council v Gems House Residences Chiltern Street Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 937, CA

Search