Almost all organisations understand that they have a duty to protect the health and safety of their employees. However, under section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act (HSWA) 1974, organisations are also obligated to avoid exposing members of the public to health and safety risks through the conduct of their business. Hampshire County Council breached this obligation.
Whilst the case involves a local authority, the principles apply to all organisations. Housing providers, for example, must mitigate the risks to members of the public who decide to use the playparks, benches and bike shelters on their premises.
As we discussed in our previous e-briefing, 'Sentencing safety-related offences within the health and social care sector', the level of fines for health and safety offences has increased significantly since the Health and Safety Sentencing Guidelines came into force. Earlier this year, BUPA Care Homes Limited was fined £1.5m on appeal also concerning a breach of section 3(1) of the HSWA 1974.
The case
A six-year-old girl was visiting Lymington in Hampshire with her family when she climbed onto a hinged iron bollard. The 69kg bollard fell to the ground and pulled the young girl with it resulting in life-changing head injuries. Until she matures, it will not be possible to identify the extent of her injuries.
It was clear that the bollard had been damaged and was inadequately secured. The Health and Safety Executive’s investigation demonstrated that the Council had received a report regarding the state of the bollard before the incident. Yet, the monthly inspections by the highways department’s personnel did not pick up on the issue. The HSE found that the highways personnel received inadequate and, in some cases, misleading training, guidance and information in order to assist them in carrying out ad-hoc and routine inspections.
Hampshire County Council was found guilty after a trial of breaching section 3(1) of HSWA 1974 and was fined £1.4m and ordered to pay full costs of £130,632.
Practical advice
It is important to ensure that risk assessments are in place for any equipment, including street furniture, that the public could use. It is also important that suitable inspection programmes are in place that account for each piece of equipment’s risks, location and frequency of use.
An inspection routine alone is unlikely to be enough. Organisations should ensure that inspections are sufficient, and inspectors and maintenance staff are appropriately trained and guided as to how to carry out the inspections. A clear mechanism for reporting, and more importantly rectifying, faults should also be put in place.
If an incident occurs, you must seek legal advice as soon as possible to ensure a suitable case strategy can be formulated.
For help with any issues raised in this briefing, please contact Lorna Kenyon.
It has been another difficult few weeks for many of us, especially those who find themselves under tier 3 restrictions.
We have submitted our response to the White Paper Consultation based on the discussion held at the “Planning for the Future - what does this mean for affordable housing” webinar we held on Fri 9 Oct
Anthony Collins Solicitors is pleased to have been ranked as a Band 1 firm once again.
Since March 2020, commercial property owners and occupiers across many sectors, whether housing associations, charities, care providers or local authorities, have been impacted by the rules regulating how they deal with their tenants and their landlords. It seems each week there is a change in policy, regulation or legislation, governing how they must respond.
On 18 September 2020, the High Court gave its decision regarding the Judicial Review of Simply Learning Tutor Agency Ltd & Others v Secretary of State for Business.
A key element of the Bill is the establishment of a duty holder regime and requirement to maintain the ‘golden thread of information’ throughout the life cycle of high-risk residential buildings
We have been working with care homes to update their contracts and advise on the risks of charging the resident a regular “top-up” or additional fee where a resident is funded through NHS CHC
The parliamentary processes are complete and the Restriction of Public Exit Payments Regulations 2020 (“the Regulations”) which cap exit payments in the public sector at £95,000 will be in force from 4 November.
As the UK’s social housing sector recovers from the initial Covid-19 outbreak and lockdown, now is the time to focus on the challenges that may emerge next.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.