A group of Anthony Collins Solicitors (ACS) experts from across our various client sectors have gazed into their crystal ball and given us a view on how 2021 is looking.
Although the decision relates to an application under the NHS Pension Scheme, it has wider implications for decision makers making similar decisions under other schemes, including the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS).
Background and decision
The Deputy Ombudsman’s decision concerned an application for ill-health early retirement by an NHS Estates Support Worker, Mr Hayes. Mr Hayes had been on long-term sick leave with several conditions including neuralgic pain since July 2008 and his employment was terminated on the grounds of capability in March 2009. NHS Pensions denied the application on the basis that Mr Hayes’s treatment was on-going and it was premature to conclude that his incapacity would be permanent, quoting at length from the medical adviser. Mr Hayes’s subsequent appeals were unsuccessful, despite the argument made on his behalf by his wife that he did not want to have further surgery due to the potential risks. The final appeal decision did not consider this argument.
The Deputy Ombudsman held that NHS Pensions misinterpreted the rules of the scheme which required it to take into account Mr Hayes’ view of whether it was reasonable to refuse the proposed treatment options (not just the medical view as to their likely risks). NHS Pensions had not done so. The Deputy Ombudsman therefore returned the decision to NHS Pensions for reconsideration and directed that they pay Mr Hayes £250 for the additional stress caused by their failure to determine his eligibility in the proper manner.
The Deputy Ombudsman also commented on the level of detail that decisions should contain. He noted that there has been a trend towards increased recognition of the duty on decision makers to give reasons, particularly in cases where some or all of the following apply:
- there is a right of appeal;
- the decision maker is acting in a judicial manner;
- the decision is of a particular significance to the individual; and
- there is no specific reason not to give reasons.
He commented that bearing these factors in mind, the level of reasoning that NHS Pensions would be required to provide in these sorts of circumstances would be “towards the upper end of the spectrum”. He went on to say that he hoped they would now provide their “full reasons in plain and simple language”.
The Deputy Ombudsman’s decision means that when giving decisions on ill health retirement, decision makers should take care to give full reasons using simple language if they refuse an application for ill-health early retirement. They should also ensure that they pay close attention to the relevant rules of their scheme and ensure these are followed.
For more information
For more advice on decisions to grant ill health retirement pensions, or in relation to appeals under the internal dispute resolution procedure, please contact Doug Mullen on 0121 212 7432 or email@example.com.
Luton Borough Council was prosecuted by the HSE late last year following an incident at a high school in which an assistant headteacher was attacked by a pupil and left with life-changing injuries.
This ebriefing looks at the proposal to set out 'public procurement principles' in the proposed procurement legislation.
Happy New Year - our first newsletter of 2021! Throughout this year we will continue to bring you news and developments relating to the charities sector.
Local authorities should be wary of reserving contracts for local suppliers, as recommended by Procurement Policy Note (PPN) 11/20. Other contracting authorities may want to maximise their use of this
Most housing practitioners have perhaps been waiting for this news since the latest lockdown was announced by the Prime Minister on 4 January 2021.
Climate change and biodiversity is an area where significantly faster changes are needed on a global and local basis.
Chris Lloyd Smith, Adrian Leonard and Lisa Whitehouse discuss the planning opportunities available to owners of businesses and how to prepare for unforeseen events.
In their 3rd podcast of the series, Chris Lloyd-Smith and Maria Ramon discuss a number of problems with and difficulties that can arise in mediation and the mechanisms they use to overcome them.
Our previous round-up began by sharing the news that two vaccines had shown very promising test results. Here we are, not even a month later, and the first vaccines have already been administered!
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.