IDAs will assess an RP’s quality of governance, assessment of risk and its risk mitigation strategies. It is not yet clear whether value for money will feature as part of all IDAs (and differing approaches have been taken during the pilot programme). The Regulator has indicated that it will take a ‘first principles’ approach, starting from the premise that the RP has a G4/V4 rating, with the onus on the RP to give sufficient assurance that they are at the appropriate governance and viability ratings. This demonstrates a marked change to the approach previously taken by the Regulator, where a move away from current straplines for an RP (in effect) had to be justified by the Regulator.
Moody’s were quoted in Social Housing magazine earlier this year as saying the financial difficulties experienced by Venture Housing Association showed the ‘limitations’ of co-regulation. The Regulator’s introduction of IDAs has been likened by Jonathan Walters, Deputy Director of Performance and Strategy, to the approaches taken by such ratings agencies and is therefore clearly intended to give greater comfort that the business plans and governance arrangements being put in place across the sector are being tested robustly against the requirements of the Regulatory Framework.
The Regulator has stated that this should not be a move back to the KLOE days of the Audit Commission, with a checklist approach to assessing an RP’s governance and financial viability. Feedback on the pilot IDAs supports the validity of this statement. Speaking at a recent Placeshapers event with Charlie Norman (Chief Executive, St Vincent's Housing Association), Richard Foster (Senior Investigation and Enforcement Advisor, HCA) reinforced the point that a bespoke approach was, and would be, taken to each IDA, with key areas of concern in relation to individual organisations identified and assessed.
The concern is whether this level of individual treatment and investigation can realistically be undertaken with every organisation, if the Regulator is to achieve its suggested programme of carrying out an IDA for every RP (owning over 1,000 units) at least every four years (with additional IDAs carried out as necessary for ‘rapidly changing’ and riskier RPs).
The IDA, if it is to be delivered in line with the approach taken to the pilot programme, will prove a useful tool for RPs. The IDA will test the strength of their business and governance arrangements to ensure they are fit for purpose and able to deliver their desired objectives, and will also deepen the Regulator’s understanding of each RP’s business. Undoubtedly there’s also the potential for the strengthening of the relationship between individual RPs and the Regulator.
However, if a ‘straitjacket’ approach is taken, it will bring into question the usefulness of the IDA and what it will add to current regulatory tools, given the ever more diverse nature of the sector and the increase in more complex governance and funding arrangements.
Both the Regulator and RPs need to keep sight of the fact that IDAs should be a means to an end – strong and effective organisations – rather than an end in themselves.
Contact Gemma Bell.
Would you know how to manage an escalating social media storm? Are you confident in your plans and policies for responding to, and managing, a prominent ‘scandal’ in your charity?
The Civil Partnership (Opposite-Sex Couples) Regulations 2019 were made on 5 November 2019 and came into force on 2 December 2019.
HMRC’s approach to underpayment of the National Minimum Wage (NMW) is getting tougher and shows no sign of abating.
HMRC’s approach to underpayment of the National Minimum Wage (NMW) is getting tougher and shows no sign of abating.
Now 2020 is here and we have welcomed in the new decade, it’s time to welcome in changes regards the contents of employee’s statement of particulars.
In December 2019, the Care Quality Commission brought its first prosecution against a local authority
The CIL was introduced under the Planning Act 2008 and the CIL Regulations 2010, which came into force in April 2010. CIL is a non-negotiable tax charged by local authorities on new developments.
The Court of Appeal’s recent decision is likely to be unwelcome news for any cash-strapped councils seeking to fund the costs of taxi enforcement through licence fees.
It is important that trustees are aware of the law relating to people who are transgender and those who identify as non-binary so that they can ensure compliance.
Earlier this year, the Charity Commission published its inquiry report into Oxfam GB, following allegations about events in Haiti in 2010 involving its staff members.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.