We are delighted to announce that our private wealth law department has continued to maintain its Band 2 position in the latest edition of Chambers and Partners High Net Worth.
The Law Commission published a report on 4 September 2019 detailing its view that electronic signatures are a valid form of executing documents.
What is a legally binding contract?
It is important to remember that contracts can form and be binding, even when the terms aren’t written down. Contracts can be created, provided there is an offer, acceptance of that offer, an intention to create a legal relationship and valid consideration has been given (some form of exchange between the parties). A legally binding contract can be formed through the exchange of emails or even over the phone, without the need for a signature.
However, there are exceptions to the general rule, one being where the contract or deed must be in writing or witnessed.
Witnessing and attesting deeds
For some documents, such as deeds, there is a requirement for it to be signed in the presence of a witness. The Law Commission is not confident that the current law allows for “remote” witnessing, i.e. where the witness is not physically present when the deed is executed. Therefore, if you are witnessing a deed, you must be physically present at the time the deed is signed for valid execution, even if the signature is in electronic form.
The Law Commission considered two potential options for the future of witnessing documents:
- Witnessing via video link through a signature platform – here the witness could attest to the fact that they have seen the document being signed, but they were not in the physical presence of the signatory.
- Digital signatures, or another type of technology, which would replace witnessing and attestation.
These are not yet valid methods of executing a deed but may become available in the future.
What is an electronic signature?
The term “electronic signature” refers to any arrangement where a document includes a signature in electronic form, for example, where a piece of paper has been signed manually, and the signature then scanned in electronically.
Digital signatures are a type of electronic signature that use certified-based digital IDs (issued by an accredited Certificate Authority or a Trust Service Provider) to identify and authenticate the signatory. As a result, they are more advanced and secure than other types of electronic signatures because they require some proof that the person signing is who they say they are.
The use of electronic signatures is covered in the European Regulations known as e-IDAS, which recognises three broad types of electronic signatures:
Simple – these include a name at the bottom of an email, a scanned signature, or ticking “I agree” on a website. This is a form of electronic signature but not a digital signature.
Advanced – these signature types require unique identification and authentication of the signatory, which allows verification of the integrity of the signed document. This is a form of electronic signature and constitutes a digital signature.
Qualified – this is the same as advanced (and therefore a digital signature), but there is an additional layer of protection built into the identification and authentication process; the signature is created by using a specific device that is regulated/approved by a qualified supervisory body.
Findings of the Law Commission’s report
The Law Commission’s report concluded that, after many years of debate and discussion, electronic signatures can be validly used to execute documents. The main findings of the report were:
- Unless the contrary is provided (either by law or document), a pragmatic approach towards signatures should be followed, in that there is not a prescribed form, type or method. The courts adopt an objective approach considering the surrounding circumstance and electronic signatures are admissible evidence in legal proceedings.
- An electronic signature can be used to execute documents, including deeds, so long as the document is authenticated and the proper formalities for execution are followed (i.e. using a digital signature). The formality requirements for executing documents can be found in existing statute, statutory instruments, contracts, or other private law instruments.
- The courts already accept various forms of non-electronic signatures such as tick boxes, marking initials and signing with a stamp, for example. The Law Commission is of the mind that electronic versions of these would likely be recognised by the courts as being legally valid.
- The Law Commission’s view is that the requirement under current law that deeds must be signed “in the presence of a witness” requires a physical presence of the witness. This should be the case where witnesses are executing or attesting documents electronically.
The Law Commission’s full report can be found here.
For more information, please contact Emma Watt.
Article drafted with assistance from Rumandeep Dhariwal.
Charities, like other organisations, may be subject to or choose to voluntarily comply with the reporting requirements under the Modern Slavery Act 2015.
The draft regulations making it mandatory for anyone entering a registered care home in England to have been double vaccinated unless they are clinically exempt were made on 22 July 2021.
In the Transforming Public Procurement Green Paper, the Government signalled its desire to increase its control over procurements by all contracting authorities.
The monthly round-up from the Anthony Collins Solicitors charities team.
Legal updates as the UK enters into stage 4 of the roadmap and legal restrictions on face coverings and social distancing are lifted.
The first disability we are going to discuss is diabetes. We begin by discussing the different types of diabetes; their similarities and differences and how we live with the disability within our day.
Tim Coolican and Freya Cassia explore the legal and practical options available to providers if a disappointing result is received following an inspection.
Following the launch of the CQC’s new strategy for how it regulates health and social care, many providers will be keen to know more about how the changes might affect them in the future.
EPC’s are not required to be served with a Section 21 notice for assured shorthold tenancies if the tenancy predates October 2015.
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.