Supreme Court publishes key decision for those working in the UK’s gig economy.
A local authority must put an asset on the list as being of community value if:
- there has been a valid nomination;
- the site is in the Council’s area;
- there is an actual current use of the site (or has been one in the recent past) which furthers the "social wellbeing or social interests" of the local community and which is not an “ancillary use”; and
- it is realistic to think that this use can (or could) continue.
Two recent decisions from the First Tier Tribunal on appeals in relation to listing have shed some – if not very much – light on the third point above, the question of use.
In General Conference of the New Church v Bristol City Council, the property in question was a church building with some land around it. In the recent past, as well as for worship and church activity, the church had been used by mums and toddler groups, Brownies, and other community organisations (though this use had dropped off). When the church closed (because the congregation had, sadly, dwindled to single figures) the General Conference proposed to sell the site. A local community group, keen to preserve both the building and the surrounding green space, nominated the site as an asset of community value.
The local authority agreed, and the General Conference appealed the decision. The Tribunal found in favour of the General Conference, on the basis that the use of the site was as a church – all other uses were, and always had been, ancillary to that use.
In Dorset County Council v Purbeck District Council, the listing application concerned playing fields which were adjacent to a school. Community groups used the playing fields in addition to their use by the school, though until very recently access was only through the school site. The school closed and community use continued – indeed a new entrance was created to allow direct access. The County Council decided it would be more sensible to sell the site and re-provide playing fields nearer the successor schools. Again, local groups applied to list the site; again, the responsible Council (Purbeck DC) agreed; and again, there was an appeal to the Tribunal.
The Tribunal found for the owner, and said that the use by community groups had always been ancillary to the main use by the school. The deciding arbiter reviewed the guidance and noted, quite rightly, that “there is no certain guidance or touchstone” in deciding these issues.
However, these two cases appear to indicate a relatively cautious approach to deciding on whether assets should be listed or not. In the General Conference case, the Tribunal did not, seemingly, consider the question of whether use as a church was, in and of itself, a use that could further the “social wellbeing” of the community (and there is surely an argument to be had that it could). Nor, in the Dorset case, did the Tribunal consider whether use as a school be held to further social wellbeing.
In both cases, the Tribunal made it clear that the matter was being decided on the facts. Nonetheless, when it comes to community value, it is clear that there remains much room for debate.
For more information
Contact David Alcock.
From 6 April 2021, it will be the responsibility of medium and large private sector organisations to assess whether contractors working through an intermediary come within the ambit of IR35.
The 'Chocolate Snowman Appeal' is an amazing initiative that Anthony Collins Solicitors' (ACS) employees take part in every year.
The Building Safety Bill (the Bill) is said to be the most significant and wide-ranging change to the regulatory environment for higher risk building (HRBs) for over 45 years.
On 4 November 2020, the Restriction of Public Exit Payments Regulations 2020 (the Regulations) came into force; exit payments for the public sector were capped at £95,000.
The case was brought by the Official Receiver who sought disqualification orders under section 6 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 (CDDA 1986) against the seven trustees of Kids Company and its CEO. It illustrates well the tension between the role of a fulltime paid CEO of a large charity and the role of its board as voluntary trustees/directors.
At the end of 2020, The Charity Governance Code was updated or 'refreshed' as it is termed on its website.
Anthony Collins Solicitors is today (Thursday 11 February) revealing the scale of its social impact during 2020.
In their first podcast of this series, current and future trainees will discuss their journey and route to securing a training contract at Anthony Collins Solicitors.
A recent prosecution by the Health and Safety Executive ("HSE") demonstrates the importance of organisations regularly inspecting, maintaining, and if necessary, repairing or replacing street furnitur
To receive invitations to our events, as well as information and articles on legal issues and sector developments that are of interest to you, please sign up to Newsroom.